Nestled in the charming town of Old Saybrook, Connecticut, you’ll discover a diverse culinary scene that is sure to delight your taste buds. From cozy diners to elegant restaurants, this coastal gem offers a variety of dining experiences that reflect the unique character of the region. Whether you’re craving seafood fresh from the Atlantic Ocean or a taste of classic American fare, Old Saybrook’s eateries have something special for everyone.
Exploring Old Saybrook through its restaurants can be a delicious adventure, providing insights into the local culture and flavors. As you stroll down Main Street or wander near the picturesque coastline, you’ll find inviting spots where both locals and visitors gather to enjoy good food and great company. Each establishment offers not only a meal but also a warm and welcoming atmosphere that adds to the charm of this beloved town.
Get a discount of 15% to 70% on accommodation in Old Saybrook! Look for deals here:
Old Saybrook Hotels, Apartments, B&Bs
Just visiting? Check out our articles on best hotels in Old Saybrook, Connecticut and best things to do in Old Saybrook, Connecticut.
Rosemary & Sage
When you’re in Old Saybrook, one place you shouldn’t miss is Rosemary & Sage. This charming restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where you’ll feel right at home. The friendly staff makes your dining experience enjoyable, ensuring you have a great meal.
The menu at Rosemary & Sage is full of delicious options. You’ll find everything from appetizers and salads to pasta and entrees. There’s truly something for everyone here, and the chefs use fresh ingredients to create dishes that will leave your taste buds happy.
If you enjoy a good drink with your meal, you’ll love their full bar. They offer specialty cocktails and a wide selection of wines, perfect for pairing with your dish. With outdoor patio seating available in warmer months, you can enjoy your meal in the fresh air.
Rating: 4.7 (294 reviews)
Location: 1080 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 388-1166
Website: Visit Website
Little Pub Old Saybrook
If you’re in Old Saybrook, Little Pub is a must-visit spot. It’s known for its rustic charm and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant is a lively place where you can enjoy great food and generous drinks. You’ll feel right at home as soon as you walk in.
The menu, crafted by Chef Tim Passaro, mixes old and new flavors. Dishes like the fish and chips or the Graceland burger will tempt your taste buds. The Graceland burger, topped with grilled bananas and Thai peanut sauce, is particularly worth a try.
Little Pub isn’t just about great food. It’s a community hub where families, friends, and co-workers gather. Their focus on fun, comfort, and excellent customer service makes it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Next time you’re exploring the shops or local attractions, stop by Little Pub. It’s conveniently located and also near several hotels and businesses. With unique features like their honey company and goat farm, it’s a unique place for a meal or event.
Rating: 4.4 (951 reviews)
Location: 1231 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 339-5591
Website: Visit Website
Fresh Salt
If you’re in Old Saybrook, a visit to Fresh Salt should be on your list. Located by the water, this place offers breathtaking views that perfectly complement its dining experience. You can enjoy a meal with friends or family while taking in the serene surroundings.
The atmosphere at Fresh Salt is warm and welcoming. The interior design creates a cozy and inviting space that makes you want to linger a bit longer. The staff is friendly, ensuring your visit feels special from start to finish.
The food here is a celebration of fresh ingredients and creative dishes. Whether you’re in the mood for seafood or a hearty main course, the menu has something for everyone. Don’t miss out on trying some popular items that have kept diners coming back for more.
Rating: 4.3 (627 reviews)
Location: 2 Bridge St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 388-1111
Website: Visit Website
Monkey Farm
In Old Saybrook, Connecticut, you’ll find Monkey Farm, a lively spot with a welcoming vibe. This café is known for its tasty sandwiches, piled high and cooked just right. If you’re looking for some comfort food, Monkey Farm is a great choice.
Monkey Farm’s menu offers specials like the Fresh Grilled Swordfish and Prime Rib Dinner. Their Blackened Scallops over Caesar Salad is a must-try. The Fried Pork Cutlet Grinder is another standout, with provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and chips on the side.
For a hearty meal, check out their soups, available in both cup and bowl sizes. Options include Cream of Spinach and White Bean with Sausage and Chicken. Dessert lovers can indulge in Apple Crisp or Banana Cream Pie, among others.
Rating: 4.3 (1100 reviews)
Location: 571 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 388-4866
Website: Visit Website
Penny Lane Pub
When you step into Penny Lane Pub, you’re greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for gathering with friends and family. Situated in the historic town of Old Saybrook, this two-story English-style pub offers a cozy neighborhood vibe.
The menu at Penny Lane Pub is a delightful mix of casual pub fare and creative daily specials. You’ll find a range of quality dishes to enjoy alongside specialty wines and a world-class beer list. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for a leisurely dinner, there’s something for everyone.
Boasting rave reviews, guests regularly comment on the good food, great service, and friendly vibe. You’ll find dishes like fish and chips and fresh salads, all at reasonable prices. It’s an experience you won’t want to miss.
Rating: 4.5 (820 reviews)
Location: 150 Main St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 388-9646
Website: Visit Website
Otter Cove Restaurant & Bar
When you’re in Old Saybrook, Connecticut, you should visit Otter Cove Restaurant & Bar. Nestled on Essex Road, it’s a warm spot with a cozy vibe. The restaurant is known for its relaxed atmosphere, which makes it perfect for families and friends looking to unwind.
You can enjoy an array of American dishes here. They offer both in-house specials and options for ordering to-go, catering to your dining preferences. With friendly staff and dishes prepared with care, Otter Cove ensures a delightful dining experience.
Besides the food, Otter Cove often has events and promotions. Whether it’s dining in or taking out, you can find specials that make your visit affordable and enjoyable. It’s a place where community and good eats come together.
Rating: 4.4 (218 reviews)
Location: 99 Essex Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 388-4836
Website: Visit Website
745 Osteria
If you’re looking for modern Italian dining in Old Saybrook, 745 Osteria is a must-visit. They offer a delightful menu filled with fresh, Italian-inspired dishes. Whether you want small plates, salads, pasta, or even Neapolitan pizza, there’s something here for every craving.
The ambiance at 745 Osteria is warm and inviting. You can enjoy a relaxed dinner here or opt for takeout if you’d like to savor your meal at home. They also offer options for gatherings, making it convenient if you’re planning an event in the Essex, Lyme, or Westbrook areas.
Behind it all is Antonio Suppa, dedicated to honoring his family’s legacy. His parents once ran a well-loved restaurant in New Haven. Now, Antonio brings the same passion and Italian flavors to 745 Osteria. It’s a place where you feel both the love and tradition in every bite.
Rating: 4.4 (201 reviews)
Location: 745 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 339-3107
Website: Visit Website
La Marea Ristorante
If you’re craving Italian cuisine, La Marea Ristorante in Old Saybrook is a must-visit. This charming, family-owned restaurant brings the flavors of northern and southern Italy right to your plate. Using fresh, locally sourced ingredients and imports from Italy, La Marea offers a unique dining experience.
The menu features seasonal updates with both traditional and modern Italian dishes. Start your meal with antipasti like the beloved Eggplant Parmesan. Then, dive into pasta dishes, seafood, chicken, or steak. Don’t miss their Wood Fired Neapolitan Pizzas, which come with gluten-free options.
La Marea also has an impressive selection of drinks to complement your meal. Try their craft cocktails, draft beers, or a carefully chosen wine. Be sure to leave room for dessert—especially the house-made Cheesecake. The staff, including owners Juliana and Nino Pisanzio, ensure a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
Rating: 4.6 (347 reviews)
Location: 732 Middlesex Ave, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 391-8614
Website: Visit Website
The Essex
You’ll find The Essex in the heart of Old Saybrook. It’s a charming spot known for its warm atmosphere and welcoming vibe. This place offers a delightful dining experience, where you can enjoy a great meal with friends or family.
The menu features a variety of dishes. Here, you can taste fresh seafood and flavorful pasta. Each dish is crafted with care and quality ingredients. You might want to try their signature dish that many locals rave about.
Rating: 4.5 (281 reviews)
Location: 247 Main St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 237-4189
Website: Visit Website
Swell
When you’re in Old Saybrook, Swell is a spot you don’t want to miss. This charming place offers a blend of smoothies and flowers, bringing a unique twist to your day out. It’s a delightful experience, whether you’re grabbing a refreshing drink or picking up a bouquet for someone special. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting.
Swell is known for its seasonal bundles. Right now, there’s a Valentine’s smoothie and flower bundle available. This combo adds an extra touch of sweetness to your day, and it’s something you won’t find just anywhere.
Located on Main Street, Swell provides easy access to both locals and visitors. Whether you’re exploring the town or looking for a quick stop, it’s an ideal location to take a break. With such a warm ambiance, you can truly enjoy a moment of relaxation.
Rating: 4.8 (27 reviews)
Location: 188 Main St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (959) 746-2078
Website: Visit Website
Culinary History of Old Saybrook
Old Saybrook, Connecticut, offers a rich culinary history that highlights its coastal charm and traditional New England recipes. The influence of the seaside location weaves into local dishes, showcasing fresh ingredients and timeless flavors.
Influence of Coastal Cuisine
Being a coastal town, Old Saybrook has a deep connection to the sea. The waters of Long Island Sound provide a bounty of fresh seafood options. You’re likely to enjoy dishes featuring clams, oysters, and lobsters that reflect this seafaring heritage.
Historical establishments often brought creativity to traditional recipes, like adding kelp to clam chowder. This innovative use of local resources keeps the culinary scene in Old Saybrook both fresh and deeply rooted in coastal fare.
Traditional Dishes and Local Ingredients
In Old Saybrook, traditional dishes use local, seasonal ingredients to capture New England flavors. You’ll find that apples, squashes, and root vegetables are staples in many recipes, often due to their abundance in the area.
The community’s agricultural past inspires dishes like corned beef and cabbage or hearty stews. The warmth and simplicity of these meals reflect the town’s history. Engaging with these local flavors gives you a taste of the area’s past and present, making your visit both flavorful and memorable.
Dining Atmosphere and Ambiance
Old Saybrook, Connecticut, boasts a rich variety of dining experiences. Whether you’re seeking a romantic setting or a laid-back family-friendly place, there’s something to suit your mood and company.
Cozy and Romantic Settings
For those looking to enjoy a meal with a special someone, Old Saybrook offers intimate settings that are perfect for a romantic night out. Liv’s Oyster Bar & Restaurant creates a warm atmosphere with soft lighting and coastal touches. The fresh seafood here is always a hit.
Cocotte @ James Pharmacy also offers a charming setting with a vintage flair. Envelop yourself in the rustic decor and enjoy dishes that focus on quality and taste. The historical charm adds an extra layer of intimacy to your dining experience. These spots make it easy to lose track of time, enjoying both good company and delicious food.
Casual and Family-Friendly Environments
If you’re dining with family, you’ll find plenty of casual options that cater to all ages. The Monkey Farm is a classic choice, offering a relaxed atmosphere with a menu to please everyone. Its friendly service and fun decor make it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike.
Saybrook Pizza & Restaurant, known for its award-winning pizzas since 1977, provides a welcoming space where you can sit back and enjoy a slice. Its laid-back vibe and delicious offerings make it perfect for family gatherings or any laid-back get-together. Both of these spots ensure you enjoy a comfortable, satisfying meal.
Unique Dining Experiences
In Old Saybrook, Connecticut, you’ll discover dining experiences that go beyond the ordinary. From farm-fresh ingredients to creative tasting menus, the local culinary scene invites you to explore and savor every bite.
Seasonal and Farm-to-Table Offerings
In Old Saybrook, restaurants like Fresh Salt and The Essex pride themselves on using seasonal, local ingredients. You’ll find menus that change with the harvest, ensuring that each dish is as fresh as possible. This commitment brings an ever-changing variety of flavors to your table.
Local farms provide a rich bounty, allowing chefs to craft dishes from just-picked vegetables and meats. The connection to the local farming community not only supports sustainability but also offers you an authentic taste of Connecticut’s countryside.
Whether it’s a crisp summer salad or a hearty winter stew, the farm-to-table approach promises an unforgettable meal made with care and creativity.
Chef’s Specials and Tasting Menus
Old Saybrook is home to creative chefs who love to surprise diners with unique specials and thoughtfully designed tasting menus. At places like Aspen Restaurant and Bar, indulge in dishes showcasing the chef’s innovation, combining unique flavors and techniques.
A tasting menu provides a curated dining journey, often with multiple small courses that highlight the chef’s best work. This allows you to sample a range of dishes in one meal, each paired with carefully selected wines or craft beverages.
Such experiences aren’t just about eating—they’re an adventure for your taste buds. Each bite tells a story of passion and expertise, ensuring that your meal is both delightful and memorable.
Get a discount of 15% to 70% on accommodation in Old Saybrook! Look for deals here:
Old Saybrook Hotels, Apartments, B&Bs
Chester, Connecticut Travel Guide – History, Travel, Hotels, and More!
Clinton, Connecticut Travel Guide – History, Travel, Hotels, and More!
Cromwell, Connecticut Travel Guide – History, Travel, Hotels, and More!
