In the quaint town of Old Lyme, Connecticut, you’ll discover a delightful mix of charming eateries and culinary delights that promise to captivate your taste buds. With its rich history and serene landscapes, Old Lyme offers not only a picturesque setting but also a diverse dining scene that caters to a variety of preferences.
What makes Old Lyme a must-visit destination for food lovers is its unique blend of traditional New England flavors and innovative culinary offerings. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh seafood, comforting pizza, or modern American cuisine, you’ll find something to savor in this coastal gem. Get ready to explore a community where food is as much an art form as the vibrant paintings in local galleries.
Get a discount of 15% to 70% on accommodation in Old Lyme! Look for deals here:
Old Lyme Hotels, Apartments, B&Bs
Just visiting? Check out our articles on best hotels in Old Lyme, Connecticut and best things to do in Old Lyme, Connecticut.
The Hangry Goose
If you are looking for a spot with good food and charming views, The Hangry Goose in Old Lyme is worth a visit. This lovely place serves breakfast and lunch daily, with dinner available from Wednesday to Saturday. You can enjoy Eggs Benedict in the morning and a tasty Bangin’ Shrimp Wrap for lunch.
Located by the water, the restaurant offers a relaxing atmosphere that’s perfect for enjoying dishes like Salmon Salad or a classic burger. They also have a menu for kids called “Hangry Littles,” making it a great place for families. The service is welcoming and you will feel right at home as you dine.
The Hangry Goose has been serving the community since 2020. Their food is fresh and the setting is delightful. It’s an ideal spot for those who love both food and nature. If you get the chance, watch the sunset during your dinner for an extra special experience.
Rating: 4.6 (463 reviews)
Location: 11 Halls Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371
Contact: (860) 434-2227
Website: Visit Website
Hideaway Restaurant & Pub
If you’re in Old Lyme, Connecticut, make sure to check out Hideaway Restaurant & Pub. This cozy spot is perfect for grabbing a bite with friends or family. The atmosphere is welcoming, making it a great place to relax and enjoy your meal. You can find everything from classic American dishes to unique specials that change daily.
When visiting Hideaway, you’ll have many tasty options to choose from. For lunch, you might try their Chicken Parm Sandwich or the American Chop Suey, both coming with generous portions. If you’re in the mood for something lighter, the Grilled Chicken Caesar is a fresh and flavorful choice. The variety ensures that there’s something for everyone.
Seafood lovers will be delighted with the P.E.I. Mussels & Linguini. These mussels are sautéed with garlic and white wine butter, served over linguini, creating a delicious and satisfying dish. For a classic option, a Fish Sandwich featuring fresh, local flounder is also available.
Rating: 4.1 (479 reviews)
Location: 19 Halls Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371
Contact: (860) 434-1455
Website: Visit Website
Old Lyme Inn
When you visit Old Lyme, you can’t miss the charming Old Lyme Inn. It’s nestled in the historic Art District along the Connecticut Shoreline. This delightful spot is a mix of comfort and culture. It offers a cozy place to stay and an experience filled with music and dining.
The inn has 13 beautifully renovated rooms that invite you to relax and enjoy your stay. If you’re a fan of live music, head to The Side Door, their famous jazz club. It’s a great place to unwind and enjoy some of the best jazz performances in the area.
Dining at Old Lyme Inn is a treat. You can enjoy delicious meals indoors or outdoors when the weather is nice. The inn is conveniently located near a variety of attractions, like museums and specialty shops, giving you plenty of activities to explore during your visit.
Rating: 4.5 (270 reviews)
Location: 85 Lyme St, Old Lyme, CT 06371
Contact: (860) 434-2600
Website: Visit Website
Sapore Pizzeria & Bar
If you’re looking for a delightful dining experience in Old Lyme, look no further than Sapore Pizzeria & Bar. This cozy spot has undergone beautiful renovations, boasting a clean and welcoming atmosphere. The decor sets the perfect backdrop for a meal you won’t forget.
Service at Sapore is top-notch. The staff is known for being exceptionally friendly and attentive, ensuring you feel comfortable throughout your visit. They’re professional yet approachable, making sure your dining experience is smooth and enjoyable.
The menu is a highlight, featuring dishes like the delectable corn ravioli. It’s packed with fresh ingredients and is beautifully presented. Whether you’re in for a pasta dish or another entrée, you and your party will be pleased with the flavors.
Don’t miss out on the cocktails, which are perfectly crafted. They strike a balance that’s refreshing and not overpowering. It’s easy to see why visitors want to return weekly for a taste of what Sapore has to offer.
Rating: 4.7 (321 reviews)
Location: 163 Boston Post Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371
Contact: (860) 390-6278
Website: Visit Website
The Stumble Inne
If you’re ever in Old Lyme, Connecticut, you must check out The Stumble Inne. This delightful spot mixes charm with a fantastic menu. Here, you can enjoy hearty salads brimming with fresh vegetables and delicious toppings. If you’re in the mood for soup, they offer options like shrimp bisque and classic New England clam chowder.
Craving a sandwich or something more substantial? The Stumble Inne has a fantastic selection of mouth-watering sandwiches and comforting platters. Try the crispy chicken sandwich or their delectable prime rib crafted carefully with tasty ingredients.
Don’t miss their delicious starters, perfect for sharing or enjoying by yourself. From calamari to chicken wings, each dish is a lovely treat. And for the burger enthusiasts, they present a juicy half-pound Angus beef burger. It’s grilled to perfection and packed with flavor.
Rating: 4.5 (22 reviews)
Location: 90 Halls Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371
Contact: (860) 434-2342
Website: Visit Website
Long River Local Farm Market & Cafe
If you find yourself in Old Lyme, Connecticut, a visit to Long River Local Farm Market & Cafe is a must. This charming spot offers a unique mix of local flavors and warm hospitality. It’s not just a cafe but a place where you can enjoy fresh, locally-sourced produce and delicious homemade dishes.
The cafe’s cozy atmosphere makes it perfect for a relaxing meal with friends or family. Nestled in a picturesque part of town, it offers a peaceful escape from the hustle and bustle. There’s something special about enjoying a meal made with care and local ingredients.
When you step inside, you’re greeted by friendly staff who are passionate about what they do. The menu features a variety of options, from hearty breakfasts to light lunches. Each dish is crafted with attention to detail, making this spot a favorite for both locals and visitors.
Rating: 4.6 (57 reviews)
Location: 96 Halls Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371
Contact: (860) 598-9086
Website: Visit Website
Papi’s Taqueria
If you find yourself in Old Lyme, Connecticut, craving Mexican food, Papi’s Taqueria is a must-visit. You’ll love the variety of fresh dishes they offer. From gringo soft-shell tacos to taquitos and veggie quesadillas, there’s something for everyone.
The chefs at Papi’s use the freshest ingredients to ensure every bite is delicious. The menu features favorites like tinga tostadas, fajita salads, and fiesta nachos. You can taste the care and quality in every dish.
Visit Papi’s Taqueria and experience the warm welcome and lively atmosphere. It’s not just about the food; it’s an enjoyable outing. Make sure you drop by for an unforgettable meal.
Rating: 4.7 (93 reviews)
Location: 19 Halls Rd, Old Lyme, CT
Contact: (860) 434-8226
Website: Visit Website
Monkey Farm
When you’re in Old Saybrook, make sure to stop by Monkey Farm. It’s a favorite with locals and visitors alike. Known for its laid-back vibe, this spot is perfect for a casual meal.
Explore their menu with mouth-watering offerings like the grilled swordfish and prime rib dinner. If you’re in the mood for something unique, try the fried pork cutlet grinder or the blackened scallops.
The cafe also has delicious soups and tempting desserts. You might find options like apple crisp or a brownie sundae on your visit. Each dish is made to please, keeping you coming back for more.
Rating: 4.3 (1100 reviews)
Location: 571 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 388-4866
Website: Visit Website
Fresh Salt
If you’re planning a visit to Old Saybrook, you might want to stop by Fresh Salt. It’s a great spot located by the water, offering lovely views and a relaxing atmosphere. You can enjoy your meal while watching the boats go by, making it a perfect choice for a laid-back dining experience.
Fresh Salt offers a mix of regional dishes with a focus on fresh ingredients. You’ll find seafood on the menu, along with other American favorites. It’s a place where both locals and visitors enjoy dining. The cozy setting and friendly staff add to the inviting feeling.
Rating: 4.3 (627 reviews)
Location: 2 Bridge St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 388-1111
Website: Visit Website## Rosemary & Sage
Nestled in Old Saybrook, Rosemary & Sage is a delightful find for food lovers. The restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere where friendly staff make you feel at home. It’s the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a meal, either inside or on the cozy patio.
The menu is diverse and caters to a wide range of tastes. Whether you crave appetizers, soups, or a hearty entree, there’s something to tempt your taste buds. The dishes are carefully made with fresh ingredients, and you’ll definitely find a favorite.
If you like pairing your meal with a drink, the full bar has it all. From creative cocktails to an impressive wine list, there’s a perfect match for any dish. This spot becomes a place not just to eat, but to enjoy good company and make new friends.
Rating: 4.7 (294 reviews)
Location: 1080 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Contact: (860) 388-1166
Website: Visit Website
Culinary Scene in Old Lyme
In Old Lyme, Connecticut, you’ll find a unique dining experience fueled by locally sourced ingredients and a mix of cultural flavors. The town’s culinary scene is rich and varied, offering everything from seafood to international cuisine, perfect for any food lover’s exploration.
Local Ingredients and Sourcing
Old Lyme’s restaurants pride themselves on using fresh, local ingredients to create delicious dishes with authentic tastes you are bound to enjoy. Many eateries partner with nearby farms and markets, ensuring high-quality produce and meat make it onto your plate.
The proximity to the coast provides an incredible selection of fresh seafood. You can expect to savor local fish, oysters, and clams, capturing the true essence of Connecticut’s maritime culture. This commitment to freshness and seasonal ingredients makes dining in Old Lyme a delightful experience.
In addition to seafood, you’ll also find a range of produce like corn, tomatoes, and berries from nearby farms. These ingredients create vibrant, flavorful dishes that reflect the community’s dedication to supporting local farmers and markets.
Cultural Influences on Cuisine
A mosaic of cultural influences shapes Old Lyme’s dining landscape, offering you a world of flavors in this charming town. You’ll find cuisines from Mexico, Italy, China, and beyond, reflecting the diverse backgrounds of the town’s chefs and residents.
Restaurants like Papi’s Taqueria bring authentic Mexican flavors that tantalize your taste buds with traditional recipes passed down through generations. You can also find mouth-watering Italian pasta dishes, fragrant Chinese culinary delights, and American comfort food.
This blend of cultures ensures there’s something appetizing for every palate, making Old Lyme a food lover’s haven. Whether you’re in the mood for familiar comfort or adventurous new flavors, you’ll find a variety of options to explore in this delightful Connecticut town.
Dining Etiquette and Tips
Understanding dining etiquette can enhance your dining experience in Old Lyme’s charming restaurants, ensuring it’s memorable and enjoyable. Whether making reservations or choosing the right attire, a few key tips can help you fit right in.
Reservation Tips
Making a reservation is often a good idea, especially at popular spots. Call ahead to secure your table, particularly for weekends and holidays. You can use restaurant websites or apps for easy booking.
If your plans change, remember to cancel your reservation. This polite gesture helps restaurants manage their seating and allows others to enjoy the space.
Keep a note of any special requests, like dietary restrictions or seating preferences, when booking. This ensures a smoother, more personalized dining experience.
Dress Codes and Dining Customs
Old Lyme has both casual and upscale dining options. For fine dining, dress codes may require business casual attire. Men might wear button-down shirts and slacks, while women could choose dresses or blouses with skirts or slacks.
Casual eateries in Old Lyme are more lenient. You might wear jeans or casual dresses, but always aim to look neat and presentable. Comfort is key, but respect for the establishment is important too.
Knowing local dining customs can make you feel more at home. In formal settings, wait to begin eating until everyone is served, and use utensils from the outside in.
Get a discount of 15% to 70% on accommodation in Old Lyme! Look for deals here:
Old Lyme Hotels, Apartments, B&Bs
Bozrah, Connecticut Travel Guide – History, Travel, Hotels, and More!
Colchester, Connecticut Travel Guide – History, Travel, Hotels, and More!
East Lyme, Connecticut Travel Guide – History, Travel, Hotels, and More!
